Mark the Calendar and Know the Rules : Every fall, from October 15th through December 7th, Medicare’s Open Enrollment Period lets you switch Medicare Advantage or Part D drug plans, move between Original Medicare and Advantage, or add, drop, or change drug coverage for the following calendar year. Any change you make during these seven weeks becomes effective on January 1st. Outside this week, you generally need a Special Enrollment Period, so circling these dates on a wall calendar and in your phone keeps the opportunity from slipping past.
Read Your Annual Notice of Change in September: Before enrollment, your Advantage or Part D plan mails an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) by September 30. This federally required document outlines next year’s premiums, copays, pharmacy networks, and drug-formulary tweaks. Set aside quiet time to scan every change and ask yourself whether the revised benefits still fit your doctors, medications, and budget; if not, plan to shop for alternatives when the window opens.
Make a Personal Benefits Checklist: Gather a fresh list of every prescription with exact dosage, your preferred doctors and hospitals, and the routine services you expect next year, such as physical therapy or diabetic supplies. Add last year’s total out-of-pocket costs from Explanation of Benefits statements. That snapshot becomes the yardstick of measuring new plans, ensuring that slick marketing never outweighs real-world numbers.
Compare Options with Medicare Plan Finder: On October 15, visit Medicare.gov/plan-compare or call 1-800-MEDICARE to run side-by-side comparisons. After entering your ZIP code, drug list, and favored pharmacies, the tool ranks plans by estimated annual cost, star quality rating, and network coverage. Because formularies and provider networks can change mid-year, scroll into the plan details page and confirm each medication’s tier and any prior-authorization rules, then double-check that your doctors and hospital are still in network.
Weigh Total Annual Costs, Not Just Premiums: A rock-bottom premium may hide high deductibles, restrictive drug tiers, or hefty specialist copays. Use the cost-breakdown table in Plan Finder to add the premium, deductible, drug copays, and cost-sharing estimate for typical doctor visits. If you travel frequently, factor in out-of-area emergency coverage; if you manage chronic illness, place extra weight on maximum out-of-pocket limits. Choosing the lowest projected yearly spend, not merely the lowest premium, avoids surprise bills in July.
Check Star Ratings and Extra Benefits: CMS star ratings run from one to five and grade customer service, quality of care, and patient safety. Plans earning four or more stars often reinvest bonus payments into richer benefits, so a slightly higher premium could buy lower drug copays or dental and vision allowances. Verify that extras—gym memberships, hearing aids, over-the-counter stipends—matter to you and aren’t just shiny add-ons masking weaker medical coverage.
Call the Plan for Final Confirmation: Before you hit “Enroll,” phone the prospective plan and read your complete medication and provider list. Ask the representative to confirm network participation and drug coverage in writing or via email. This extra step creates documentation if access problems arise in January and also uncovers network updates not yet pushed to Medicare’s database.
Submit Your Enrollment by December 7: You can enroll online through Plan Finder, phone with 1-800-MEDICARE, directly on the insurer’s website, or via a licensed agent. The method does not matter as long as the plan receives your request no later than December 7 at 11:59 p.m. Eastern. Print or screenshot your confirmation number and file it with your ANOC. Expect a new ID card in the mail by late December; if it does not arrive, call the plan immediately.
Review Your January Statements: In the new year, present your new card at the pharmacy and doctor’s office, then scrutinize the first Explanation of Benefits to ensure copays and deductibles match what Plan Finder predicted. If discrepancies appear, contact the plan within the first 90 days—you may qualify for a Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1–March 31) to make one additional switch or return to Original Medicare if the new coverage is unworkable.
Set a Mid-Year Checkpoint: Even a well-chosen plan can drift off target if prescriptions change or providers leave the network. Mark a reminder in June to tally year-to-date costs and flag any emerging friction. That mid-year audit arms you with questions for the coming September’s ANOC and helps you decide early whether another switch will be wise next fall.
We understand that Medicare can be confusing. Between the coverage choices, enrollment deadlines, and yearly changes, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. That’s where we come in.
Our services are 100% free, and we’re here to help you understand everything. Whether you’re looking to switch plans during Open Enrollment or just trying to understand your current coverage, you don’t have to navigate it alone.
With expert guidance and personalized support, we’ll help you find a plan that fits your needs and bring you peace of mind.
I’m a licensed insurance broker based locally and certified to offer a wide range of Medicare options, including Medicare Advantage, Prescription Drug Plans, and Medicare Supplement coverage. I work with many of the leading carriers contracted with Medicare and can help answer your questions and guide you through your choices with confidence.
